• Lose Yourself in A Good Book

    Discover the excitement at Mystery to Me - Join a Mystery Book Club, meet authors and be transported to the heart of the mystery! And check out the growing selection of "Something Other Than Mystery!"

  • Mystery To Me, an independent bookstore

    Mystery to Me! Your neighborhood bookstore now featuring a great selection of books for children and young adults.

Welcome to Mystery To Me

Connect With Us:
















6th Annual Walk for Dyslexia

May 16, 2015

Join the Mystery to Me Team by clicking on the Walk Logo above! 

If you can't make it to the Walk, make a pledge to support this incredible non-profit! 



Welcome to Mystery to Me, an independent bookstore located at 1863 Monroe Street in Madison, Wisconsin.   

The mystery genre offers a wide selection of everything from cozies and historical mysteries to thrillers and police procedurals. In addition to mystery we have a small non-mystery nook along with a growing selection of work by local authors that includes everything from poetry to memoir. We also have a growing selection of children and young adult titles. 

We can order any type of book for you!