• Lose Yourself in A Good Mystery

    Discover the excitement at Mystery to Me - Join a Mystery Book Club and be transported to the heart of the mystery!

  • Mystery To Me Opens

    Mystery To Me Bookstore Opened on June 15, 2013 with great success and a receptive audience

Welcome to Mystery To Me

Connect With Us:


 Join Mystery to Me at the 5th Annual Walk for Dyslexia. Saturday, May 17, 2014! 



Support the Madison Public Library by ordering Nevada Barr's new book, Destroyer Angel from Mystery to Me. 20% of all sales will support the library. More information about Nevada Barr's visit at Lunch for Libraries.

Attend the BIGGEST BOOK CLUB EVER with Nevada Barr!  


Welcome to Mystery to Me, an independent bookstore located at 1863 Monroe Street in Madison, Wisconsin. 

The mystery genre offers a wide selection of everything from cozies and historical mysteries to thrillers and police procedurals. In addition to mystery we have a small non-mystery nook along with a growing selection of work by local authors that includes everything from poetry to memoir. We also have a growing selection of children and young adult titles. 

We can order any type of book for you!