• Lose Yourself in A Good Book

    Discover the excitement at Mystery to Me - Join a Mystery Book Club, meet authors and be transported to the heart of the mystery! And check out the growing selection of "Something Other Than Mystery!"

  • Mystery To Me, an independent bookstore

    Mystery to Me! Your neighborhood bookstore now featuring a great selection of books for children and young adults.

Welcome to Mystery To Me

Are you interested in working at Mystery to Me? 

Click here for details about our general bookseller position

Click here for more info about our Event Manager position


March Newsletter

Welcome to Mystery to Me, an independent bookstore 

located at 1863 Monroe Street in Madison, Wisconsin.   

Mystery to Me… and more for you

---Wide variety of mystery from across the genre

---Carefully selected fiction and non-fiction

---New York Times best-sellers

---Local interest titles

---Delightful children’s area including middle school and young adult titles

---Puzzles, mystery games, cards and more.

Our website features our complete inventory and access to a database of more than a million in-print titles. Shop on-line by ordering titles that are listed as being on our shelves and/or place a special order for that one-in-a-million. Don’t see the book you’re looking for? Give us a call or send an email.

Choose from in-store pick-up or mail-order.


Interested in Audiobooks? Click on the graphic here to learn how you can have an audiobook and support Mystery to Me!


Virtual Tour

Image of bookstore, virtual tour

Connect with Us

Facebook IconTwitter Icon