• Lose Yourself in A Good Book

    Discover the excitement at Mystery to Me - Join a Mystery Book Club, meet authors and be transported to the heart of the mystery! And check out the growing selection of "Something Other Than Mystery!"

  • Mystery To Me, an independent bookstore

    Mystery to Me! Your neighborhood bookstore now featuring a great selection of books for children and young adults.

Welcome to Mystery To Me


December Gift-Giving News and Upcoming Events

Welcome to Mystery to Me, an independent bookstore located at 1863 Monroe Street in Madison, Wisconsin.   

Mystery to Me… and more for you

---Wide variety of mystery from across the genre

---Carefully selected fiction and non-fiction

---New York Times best-sellers

---Local interest titles

---Delightful children’s area including middle school and young adult titles

---Puzzles, mystery games, cards and more.

Our website features our complete inventory and access to a database of more than a million in-print titles. Shop on-line by ordering titles that are listed as being on our shelves and/or place a special order for that one-in-a-million. Don’t see the book you’re looking for? Give us a call or send an email.

Choose from in-store pick-up or mail-order.

Connect with Us